
For those of you who frequent the YouTube space on the internet, you may have heard of the wide sweeping changes that YouTube has put into effect as of January first. Originally meant as a response to YouTube being sued by the Federal Trade Commission or FTC and the New York Attorney General, the lawsuit proved that Google and YouTube, owned by the former, was in violation of COPPA, the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act. Google had to pay out a whopping $170 million dollar fine for the violation for its collection of the personal data of minors without their parents’ consent. This data is collected in order to place targeted ads on video content. I won’t go too far into that because COPPA actually isn’t what I’m going to talk about today.
This post isn’t about the enormous ramifications that COPPA, while well meaning, is having on YouTube’s content creators themselves. I’ll leave that up to Matthew Patrick at the Game Theory/Film Theory channel who does a far more detailed deep dive and can give a personal accounting of the issue. I’m not a YouTuber, after all, I’m a blogger. His video on COPPA and it’s affects on video creators can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pd604xskDmU&t=966s
Then why mention it at all?
Because I want to talk about the changes YouTube put into effect in response to this suit. These new policies went into effect on January 1st, 2020. No big deal right? YouTube should be a safer place for our kids, right?
Well, yes, but at the same time, as a mother of a toddler, these changes are, well…
They’re a pain in my ass.
‘Holy jammers, Journeys, what the blob?’ you might be thinking.
That’s right. I said it. These new policies are a pain in the ass for parents. Sound cray cray? Let me explain.
So in our household, as well as many, many others, we use streaming services instead of cable. Hulu, Netflix, Disney +, etc. Out of all of these, for us, YouTube is king. It’s got Paw Patrol but also FilmComicsExplained. There’s HomeschoolPop and also Gordon Ramsey swearing at gross restaurant kitchens. Wanna learn how to play Pewdiepie’s Congratulations song on piano? Watch Live PD while doing laundry or just put some sweet, soothing jazz on for Quiet Time? All this and more. It has something for everyone and everything.
On that note, we let Little Maxwell have her “tv time” in the mornings. I put on whatever show it is that she wants to watch that day on YouTube while I go and do housework or write. A lot of times, I would use the ‘queue’ feature to manually add things for her to watch that would keep her interest, that she wanted to see, and that I knew were age appropriate. Other times, I would put on a pre-made playlist either for simple entertainment or for our homeschool. It would have things like the HomeschoolPop videos, book read alouds, Kids Academy, and Emily Arrow’s book songs.
Now you can just forget about that shit.

In order to make their site more “child friendly”, despite the fact that is exactly what the YouTube Kids app is for, YouTube made the following changes to what I’ll call YouTube Main, their main site.
No longer can you:
- Comment
- Add to a playlist of any kind
- Get notifications even if you are a subscriber to that channel.
- Become a Member of a channel.
Those are just for us, as viewers. The changes on a creator/channel level are even larger. What’s the big deal about these being locked down on kids videos now?
I can’t put together homeschooling playlists anymore.
I can’t be notified when my daughter’s favorite channels post new story videos.
I won’t be able to help support my favorite channels with a Membership.
I won’t be able to vet the content that my child sees as well or as easily.
Say I’m scrolling through the recommended feed looking for the latest ProfessorStick video and see that an upcoming read-aloud channel did a video of Little Maxwell’s favorite book. I won’t be able to add that video to my Watch Later list or the playlist I have that’s three-year old appropriate. The best I can do is give it a Like and hope I remember to go scroll through my Liked Videos history later to find it after I sacrifice my brain cells on the altar of debunked Flat-Earther claims.
Now I could always put it on a show and just leave it up to the Auto-Play feature to steer her to the next video, right?
You know nothing, John Snow.
Leaving it on autoplay inevitably leads to a different show than the sweet Draw So Cute episode that you left it on and that one leads to another show and so on. Before you know it, your kid is watching something you would really rather not have them watch, like some sort of badly animated freak show excuse for children’s programming.
Sorry, Little Maxwell, you’re show is f*cking creepy. Swerve!
You turn it back to the original, parent-approved safe show on a flat Color Form kid going on adventures, but by then the damage has been done. They’ve been exposed to aforementioned freak show and decide that it’s their new favorite.
Thanks, YouTube. Thanks a lot.
The point I’m getting at is that every time YouTube has some scandal and puts new policies in place to fix it, they tend to…overcorrect. And the nasty thing about overcorrecting is that it often leads to you driving, screaming, right into the path of other unsuspecting motorists.
Unfortunately, this time it’s the creators and the users, the parents, that are left confused and bleeding on that pavement.
With Peace and Passion.
Ta!
Additional Resources:
*FTC.Gov: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2019/09/google-youtube-will-pay-record-170-million-alleged-violations
*MattPat’s video on COPPA and Youtube’s Changes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pd604xskDmU&t=966s

















